Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum’s Guarding Stars is a predictable and corny Christmas romance; exactly what the fans of the genre need.
Director: Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum
Genre: Holiday, Rom-Com
Run Time: 110′
Rated: TV-14
Release Date: November 18, 2026
Where to Watch: Netflix
It’s that time of the year again. The time in which both traditional TV channels like Hallmark and streamers like Netflix start releasing their feel-good Christmas romances. And Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum’s Guarding Stars is the latest offering from the most famous of the streaming giants, a surprisingly action-packed (for the genre), predictably corny and sufficiently romantic movie that benefits from game performances and a sincere tone.
Nobody watches a film like Guarding Stars expecting something great, so that’s not what it’s on offer here. What it does offer, though, is a solid hundred minutes of cheesy nonsense and big emotions; exactly what its target audience is expecting.
Leighton Meester (of Gossip Girl fame) plays Hannah Brooks, a former Afghanistan vet who now works as a professional bodyguard alongside his team: comms specialist Taylor (Rachael Ancheril, of Running Point), ex-boyfriend Robbie (Toby Sandeman) and boss Doghouse (wrestler CM Punk). As the film starts, we see her saving a VIP from a bomb in New York, and then refusing a paid leave from her co-workers, as her mum has recently passed and she is supposed to be grieving. Instead, she accepts a new job: flying to Montana in order to protect movie star Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki, of Gilmore Girls and Supernatural fame) from a crazy stalker. He’s going back home to spend Christmas with her family and visit her sick mum, Connie (Andie MacDowell), at the hospital.
So, travel to Montana is what Hannah does, even if her first encounter with her new client isn’t the most comfortable. He doesn’t see her as a bodyguard, and she isn’t used to dealing with eccentric Hollywood actors. But after a misunderstanding (typical of the genre), Hannah’s team decides she must pose as Jack’s new girlfriend, which, of course, results in all sorts of shenanigans and ultimately, in the pair falling in love with one another. But there are a couple of problems. Firstly, they must keep Jack out of the limelight, as Hannah and her team don’t know where the stalker is. And secondly, he must deal with traumas from the past, which were in fact the reason he hadn’t been home for a while.
Plot-wise, there’s nothing new in Guarding Stars. The movie feels like a cross between The Bodyguard and Miss Congeniality, with gender-swapped characters compared to the former, and Hannah going through a classic makeover, much like in the latter. Throw in a couple of unexpected action scenes, and Guarding Stars turns into a palatable, predictable and entertaining experience, which manages to delight its audience by accepting its clichéd nature and the fact that pretty much everyone knows how the story will end.
The only thing that truly matters in a film like this, then, is that the romance feels believable, and thankfully that’s the case in Guarding Stars. From the first moment they meet, Hannah and Jack manage to look the part, with the former being impressed by Jack’s hidden depths, and the latter liking Hannah’s strength (both physical and emotional) and her general badassery. In other (maybe better) movies, the initial conflict between them (before they fall in love) might feel tighter and more intense, but here, it never manages to turn into anything truly dramatic. Yes, at first, Hannah doesn’t necessarily think of Jack as boyfriend material, but it doesn’t take long for her to fall for him despite their professional relationship.
Speaking of which, Hannah’s job never turns into an impediment to her starting a relationship with Jack at the very end (were you expecting a different outcome?). Even her co-workers seem pretty excited for her, despite usually behaving in pretty unbelievable ways; Meester is surprisingly credible as a capable bodyguard and ex-soldier, the others, not so much. And even though Jack’s family is needed in the story in order to give him a dramatic past, they also never become an obstacle or even an interesting hurdle for them to be together. At a certain point, Jack gets into a fight with brother Hank (Noah LaLonde) due to some unresolved issues, but it’s all resolved rather quickly.
If you were expecting something deeper or more suspenseful from Guarding Stars, then I don’t know what to tell you, apart from “it’s not that kind of movie”. Meester is great as Hannah, playing her as a badass with a soft heart, and Paladecki is quite charismatic as a prototypical action star (the kind who doesn’t do his own stunts). Locations look good and cosy, with Canada passing as Montana to this Latino critic’s eyes, and the action scenes, while not extraordinary, manage to give the movie an unexpected edge. Ultimately, though, Guardian Stars is exactly what I was expecting: a corny, sexless, well-acted, sweet, predictable and at times unbelievable rom-com. Nothing more, but thankfully nothing less.
Guarding Stars (Netflix): Movie Plot & Recap
Synopsis:
A professional bodyguard is sent to Montana to protect a movie star, and ends up posing as his girlfriend in order to hide him from a crazy stalker.
Pros:
- Game performances.
- Suitably romantic and corny.
- Occasionally amusing.
- Christmassy enough.
- As predictable as a movie like this should be.
Cons:
- Underdeveloped secondary characters.
- Some really unbelievable moments.
- The end twist comes out of nowhere.
Guarding Stars is now available to stream globally on Netflix. Read our reviews of A Dog’s Perfect Christmas, A Merry Little Ex-Mas and Hot Frosty!